Talk:Charlie Swan/@comment-86.186.216.153-20100611173750

i love charlie, i think its so sweet of him to protect her and i know that Edward and Bella are in love but it's not his fault that he can't see it like they do. i understand charlie alot, he gave Edward a chance and then in new moon Edward left Bella, and charlie had to go day by day, month by month watching his daughter messed up because of 1 guy. i love Edward to bits but i don't blame charlie for acting like that....just imagine if a boy broke you're daughter's heart like Edward did, would you like him?, because i definitely wouldn't