User blog comment:Morningleaf/Why?/@comment-1382296-20090902085353

Ok, i'm for Edward here. Edward is sweet, caring and funny. He is only over protective because he experienced what it feels like to lose Bella forever, and he does not ever want to experience that kind of pain again. I don't know what you mean by he is annoying. He is mean? To the werewolves do you mean? I don't think he is mean to the werewolves. Ever since Eclipse he has been grateful to Jacob for being there for Bella when he wasn't. In Breaking Dawn he doesn't hate Jacob anymore and even calls him his brother. Whereas Jacob, on the other hand, ever since he became a werewolf, has hated the vampires and not made that fact quiet either.

I think the human Jacob was pretty awesome. But his appearance in the books is so brief, that you don't get a chance to feel attached to him. And then comes the bitter, hateful Jacob, who kisses Bella without her permission! Who is also a bit of a jerk and tricks her into kissing him.

I do love Jacob but I think Edward is better.