Talk:Renesmee Cullen/@comment-24927180-20140528050610/@comment-24927180-20140624011021

I get that, I know what was said between Bella and Jake, but it doesn't change that to me it came off as  Renesmee is just Jacob's part two of Bella.

She is shown that way in the whole book after Jacob imprinted.

While, I get and respect your view on it, I just can't see it from that way.

For me Jacob's imprinting on Renesmee is shown as a disturbing way of him getting what he wants because he can't have the natural path, so he has to take the supernatural to get a piece of what he wanted from the start.

It would have made more sense for his supernatural path to be away from Bella,  as Edward was someone that Jacob never felt anything towards, and as the nesscery second genetric donor to Renesmee, Jacob should have felt a pull with Edward as well. (Just as friends)

The fact that he imprinted on Renesmee is just a horrible plot device to make sure that Jake was around for Bella even after she became a vampire.

I find the whole imprinting on children morally wrong, let alone imprinting on the daughter of the woman you wanted to be with.

At the end I find that imprinting is toxic, from Jake and Renesmee to Sam and Emily,  it's a recipe for an emotionally abusive realtionship.

But, that's just the way that I personally see it.

I got off point again.

I can't stop doing the thing.

I'm sorry.