Talk:Charlie Swan and Sue Clearwater/@comment-65.9.204.178-20140512040601/@comment-7600752-20140513041750

The movies are NOT written by Meyer, but by movie writers who base their work on Meyer's books. The movies are good...but don't always match up perfectly with the books. But, most readers of the Twilight Saga, view it by according to what Meyer wrote. In NEW MOON, it's constantly hinted that Harry Clearwater was in bad health... we are ONLY told that Harry dies...but with no explanation but he had a heart-attack. Meyer has explained in interviews that Harry's heart attack was caused by both his children suddenly turning into wolves in his presence, while in their home. Sue, Leah, and Seth are mentioned in NEW MOON. In fact, Bella, Charlie, Harry, Sue, Leah, and Seth all attend a spaghetti supper at Jacob and Billie Black's house. But, the movie had Harry die by having a heart attack because Victoria began to attack him, but was stopped by the wolves. Although I like this version better...it NEVER happened in the book NEW MOON. In fact, Victoria is never actually seen by Bella...who is telling the story. Jacob tells Bella that he and the wolf pack members have seen Victoria...and detected her scent in the forest.