Talk:Alistair/@comment-3536164-20110429211853/@comment-194.80.178.253-20121005160638

I think that is highly unlikely cuz Victoria was born 100 years after Carlisle was born and Hilda originally came from Germany so was there around the time Carlisle was turned. Plus i believe that Edward told Bella that it was a male vampire that bit Carlisle when he was telling her about Carlisle's past in Twilight.