Talk:Jacob Black/@comment-24927180-20140916181106/@comment-7600752-20150118231021

^ Uhhhh, No. This was part of the book - not something the director, or screen writer wrote in. In fact, I don't think it even made it into the movie. BUT, I think what Jacob was doing was just trying to lighten the mood a bit. Everyone was literally sick and tired of the was Rose was acting - like she was in charge of everything. Edward was about ready to rip her apart - Jacob noticed this, so he began teasing Rose. Then she brought the "dog dish" with Jacob's food. So, he flung the dish at her. Everybody knew Jacob was trying to be funny - and lighten the mood. I know Sethnesmee is going to make this look cruel and abusive - but Jacob KNEW that the dish wasn't going to hurt Rose. In fact, it didn't - it ended up just bouncing right off her - just a bit of food got in her hair. She wasn't the least bit hurt (maybe her pride was hurt). But Jacob wouldn't have flung the dish if he thought Rose could get hurt. But, it bullets won't hurt her, then I doubt that the dog dish would have hurt her either. Which it didn't