Talk:Stephenie Meyer/@comment-3426097-20111113201848/@comment-4606351-20111217200409

How can you hate Harry Potter?! It's characters have growth and actual emotions. The only emotions Bella feels is depression and lust, both caused by Edward. Harry feels a whole range of emotions such as anger, happiness, sadness, lonely, confusion, longing and love (The list goes on!) and they are all caused by different things in his life! The female characters aren't afraid to stand up for themselves without a man in front of them. Hermione is a perfect role model to girls, she's smart and she didn't need Ron to hold her other hand when she punched Malfoy in the nose did she? Ginny is just plain awesome, she wasn't afraid to help her friends fight one of the best duelists in Britain (Bellatrix Lestrange). If Angela was being killed by Victoria, what would Bella do? Scream "Edward help!" while running away from Victoria tripping the whole time. J.K. Rowling was going through a tough spot when she wrote Harry Potter and then her mother died halfway through writing the first book, yet she pushed on through her depression and finished the book. If Stephenie Meyer's mother died halfway through writing Twilight, she would have slipped into depression and deleted Twilight from her computer, plus she was living a perfect life, 3 sons, a husband, 2 sisters and 3 brothers! J.K. Rowling wasn't conceited enough to be in the film about her own books! She was offered to play the part of Lily in the Mirror of Erised in the 1st film but she denied the offer, Stephenie Meyer was in the first Twilight as a woman sitting on the stool with her laptop, totally not needed! The Twilight saga is so predictable, you know after reading the first few chapter that Bella would marry Edward and become a vampire. Who would have guessed that Snape loved Lily even though he hated Harry for being like his father. Sirius Black vs Jacob Black, come on that isn't even a hard question. Sirius BLACK, Jacob BLACK. Sirius had a flying motorcycle, Jacob had a plain motorcycle. Sirius transforms into a giant black dog (Which in the wizarding world represented death) Jacob transforms into a giant wolf which represented absolutely nothing at all. Sirius actually has faults (Which everyone has, that doesn't make him a rubbish character) he is rash, short-tempered and slightly arrogant, whereas Jacob is the classic perfect character, good looking, a special trait and in love with the main character. Even Robert Pattinson exspressed that he hated Edward and played him as a manic-depressive, which he is. "Crooked smile", does he have wonky lips or something? At least in Harry Potter, the character that can cause the most pain isn't a little girl (Jane). And that is why Harry Potter is better than Twilight :)