User blog comment:Gcheung28/Wikia Book Club: Breaking Dawn Discussion Two/@comment-4721925-20121019074138

(I think that Jacob did not do the right thing, but it had to happen eventually, Still Jacob did a reckless thing)
 * What did you think about Jacob's decision to bring Charlie to the Cullens after Bella's transformation?

(He could have given Charlie a heart attack and It should have been done differently)
 * What about when he phased in front of him? Should Jacob have done things differently?

(Well, Bella had to hide the secrets due to it would have been the end of her family, friends and the end for herself)
 * As a father, it must have been painful for Charlie to suddenly find out about all the secrets Bella had been keeping from him. Do you think she should have tried to be honest with him from the start?

(Yes, but no at the same time, I think Charlie knew from the first day he meet Edward)
 * Why or why not? Did you find Charlie’s reaction to Bella’s transformation credible?

(I was on Team Switzerland to begin with)
 * Before we found out about Jacob's imprint, were you Team Edward or Team Jacob? Did those feelings change after reading about the imprint?

(Yes, but it is kinda confusing though O_o)
 * Meyer suggests that Jacob imprinted on Nessie even before she was born (possibly before she was even conceived), which might explain why the bond between Jacob and Bella has always been so strong. Do you find this explanation satisfying?

(Jacob's love for Bella was real)
 * Does this mean that the choice Bella made between Edward and Jacob was unnecessary on some level because Jacob’s love for her wasn’t “real?”

(A mix between the both of them, but one would be stronger then the other one)
 * Throughout the series, the vampires have displayed a wide variety of special talents. However, until Renesmee’s arrival, we never saw talents passed from one generation to the next. If Alice and Jasper were able to have a child, what might their baby’s special talent be?

(A mix between the both of them, but one would be stronger then the other one)
 * How about Esmee and Carlisle? Rosalie and Emmett?

(Yes and no, it depends)
 * Renesmee’s talent allows her to communicate in a very unique way. Breaking Dawn presents innocent uses of her talent. However, do you think her talent will mature as she does? For example, do you think she could someday be able to manipulate images to show people what she wants them to see?

(It would basically give them, the most powerful gift of all. Renesmee would be wanted world wide)
 * How could this give the Cullens an advantage if the Volturi were to reappear?

(Yes, because the packs had killed her Laurent and it would have been a wonderful payback in her point of view.)
 * When Irina ran away after seeing Jacob, did you expect her to betray the Cullens?

(A mix between all them)
 * Do you think she made her decision more from the pain of losing Laurent to a shifter or from losing her mother to the Volturi?

My Answers are in the bracketts, so please go ahead in add them to the Discussion next time. Since I will not be able to make it due to timelines.