Talk:Emily Young/@comment-3518524-20140908021529/@comment-16811522-20140914162311

New Moon does say Leah was a senior, but you got Sam's case wrong again.

Jacob says Sam was supposed to go to college, but didn't. Likewise, the Guide says Sam was a senior when he phased; Leah was a junior. Therefore, Leah being a senior in New Moon is correct, and it is correct for the book and Guide that Sam is no longer in school in New Moon.

There's still a contradictory in the timeline, true.