Talk:Jacob Black and Renesmee Cullen/@comment-2227927-20110720180750/@comment-66.138.59.116-20130422020539

I see your viewpoint. If there had never been any vampires or Edward, Bella & Jake would have been together. Jacob's love for Bella is just as valid as Edward's. There is definetly a part of Bella that was also in love with Jacob. When Bella gave birth and then turned to a vampire, her human/natural love for Jake was transferred to Renesmee. So, in a way, Jacob did end up with Bella - but it's the Bella that still exist in the human part of Renesmee. I also am not a fan of "imprinting" but it was Myer's method of giving everyone what they want, thus a happy ending. It's important to keep in mind that "imprinting" has nothing to do with eroticism or sex. It's an intense love, but not necessarily romantic, although if the imprentee is at a certian age it could be possible. Imprinting is just a tricky thing to try to comprehend.