Talk:Bella Swan and Edward Cullen/@comment-71.99.11.68-20120523003820

Here's a hypothetical situation for everyone who thinks Edward and Bella are the ultimate love. Let's just say that Edward was dirt poor, lived in a trailer at the bottom of a rock quarry, and looked like Jack Black. Everything else about him though (his backstory, his abilities, his personality) was exactly the same. Now, think about that and ask yourself if Bella would still have fallen in love with him or would she have treated him the same as all the other male characters?

Or how about this; would Edward have fallen in love with Bella if her blood smelled like moldy onions and he was able to hear her thoughts from the start? (Because personally, five pages of reading her constant internal whinning made me want to punch Bella in the face).