Talk:Eclipse movie reviews/@comment-1911348-20100809220727

This movie isn't really a comparison of just one but actually two books. The Eclipse movie combined what it could from the actual Eclipse book and the novella The Short Second Life Of Bree Tanner. When dealing with the comparison with the actual book it was fairly accurate except for when it left out a few characters such as Vera, Peter, Charlotte, Brady and Collin, not to mention most of the imprints like Kim and Claire. Although they were mostly minor roles I am sad that they were not in there. Oh well. Also I was a little worried about the fight scenes because since Bella wasn't in the battle for obvious reasons we didn't know what we would see but from what Stephenie Meyer has described from newborn tactics and the wolves style of attack I am glad to say that this was a believeable and engaging fight. The kissing scenes were a bit of a soft spot for me however. Bella's relationship with Edward is a bit strained and I still don't see the connection but that is another story for another time. The kisses shared between her and Edward were chaste and sweet while the two between her and Jacob were more...passionate, I suppose that's a good worrd to use. In a way these kisses reflect the parts of the guy's personalities and althuoght they didn't always go by the book I say the Eclipse movie was the best so far. Can't wait to see what they do with Breaking Dawn.