Talk:Volturi confrontation/@comment-72.130.23.73-20130504201625/@comment-7600752-20131220084937

I know that Meyer really likes Emmett. But I don't understand why she would object to Emmett beinig killed in the battle scene. It NEVER actually occurs....so he would be alive nevertheless. I mean....we see Carlisle decapitated and killed.....same for Jasper. The last image we see of the battle is through Aro's eyes. Just before Aro's head is consumed by fire...he sees both Bella and Edward overtaken by the Volturi guard....so we know they don't live either. I think it strange that Meyer would intervene and stop the 'plan' to have Emmett killed as well. BUT...whatever.