Talk:Bella Swan/@comment-180.244.150.185-20120528154504

i must say i agree with the critics. for me bella's infatuation with edward is kinda...obsessive? i think twilight saga is also too fairy-tail-ish, with their happily ever after endings with the minimalistic death from the good side. at least harry potter gives a way more rational ending, something that we all can relate, which makes all of us understand how horrible a war is

i love rosalie more - okay she can be bitchy and she used to be extremely vain - but when i read her pass in eclipse, i have to say i love this girl more than bella. rosalie truly lives in reality. she regrets not being able to choose whether she wanted to be a vampire or not - yes, but she tries to cope with her new condition. bella - meh, she's selfish. she wants to be with edward to the point of becoming suicidal when edward leaves her in NM - come on, it's not like we'd actually do what she does there when we're broken-hearted

the fact that jacob imprints on reneesme. a 17 years old and a baby. the moment i read that part in BD i honestly wanted to puke. i remembered something when i watched eclipse there was a part when jacob and bella kissed each other. let's see. one day reneesme is going to be an adult and have a relationship with jake, and let's say they kiss. isn't that kinda disgusting? you're kissing a guy your mom has kissed? moreover it makes me think that jacob is so desperate that he thinks if i can't get bella, then her daughter is fine

and the endings of breaking dawn. what kind of cowardly ending is that, with the volturi leaving? we all know how strong they are and that they also have some witnesses in the first place - who leave one by one as the conversations keep on going. and edward also notes that the volturi were afraid of them. there're two tiny things that maybe Stephanie Meyer had passed.

the volturi have chelsea. why didn't they just bind their witnesses to the volturi so they wouldn't be able to run away and leave? most witnesses are wanderers, so technically they should be easier to bind then those who are a part of a coven

the volturi have renata, their physical shield. why didn't they just use it the way bella does and protect everyone in Volturi from any physical attacks while they're all pointing their attacks on those who have special power? (edward, jasper, alice, the shape-shifters, eleazar, kate, etc.)

i do hope it can be understood and maybe some twilight fans will be able to give a clear answer with cool head, after all, i'm just voicing my opinion here