Talk:Charlie Swan/@comment-2098206-20100603030703

He hates both because He has been hurt really bad by Renee. He still loves her. And He just doesn't want his baby girl hurt like that. So he really does hate him after the whole James thing. Then when Edward leaves he gets to see his baby break down into a deep depression. So I think at this point he really wants to kill him. But as a parent myself I understand. I really love Charlie.