Talk:Jacob Black and Renesmee Cullen/@comment-24927180-20140601212909/@comment-24927180-20140725045027

I had thought at first that Edward most of known the old pack, but since the new pack didn't know anything, and there was people alive when the old pack were running around than it would have had to be known that they were shapeshifters; since the new pack didn't know I figured it was impossible the old did know. The whole point of the council was to pass on the lore of their tribe.

Yeah, and that's the other thing, Edward didn't even know that the wolves changing were caused by vampires, so how did he know what they were if he didn't know the simple things about them?

He also acts like it's the first time he's read their minds in Breaking Dawn/Eclipse whenever he says it's amazing to hear them all that way, so...honestly what we've just stumbled onto is a plot hole which isn't that surprising as Meyer is not good at connecting the piceces she puts down.

I've noticed that a lot in Twilight though.

She doesn't think much outside of making sure Bella (herself) gets a happy ending.