User talk:Charmed-Jay/@comment-1894108-20100903092427

I wonder whether we will ever agree on Renesmee's gift. I am finally reading Breaking Dawn, and while I don't pretend to have yet gone through the whole Book 3, I made a point to find out the scenes where they are discussed: pages 446 and 593 of the atom books paperback edition as sold by Amazon.co.uk. It is only made clear that Bella is a shield-maker, Renesmee a shield-breaker, Edward is a reader, Renesmee is a talker - even the canon is confused about how these opposites relate. And if we want to state there _is_ a relationship between Nessie's gifts and her parents we have to go back to canon, either because it is expicitly there or because it is implied there. Thus far, I failed to find any connection.