Talk:Jacob Black and Renesmee Cullen/@comment-24927180-20140601212909/@comment-7600752-20140607063147

The movie version of Jacob reacts totally different from the book version. The movie version puts all these clips in of Jacob fantasizing about an adult Renesmee. Even when Jacob FIRST sees' Renesmee he see's her for a moment as an adult. Stuff like this is constantly going on in the movie...even at the end when Alice see's a future adult Renesmee and Jaccob together. As readers, you and I KNOW that NONE of this stuff took place. It was all made up for the movie. So try to view things more by the books. The scriptwriters took free reign over these movies and ended up changing many things. But the line that Jacob said...the book version would have NEVER said that. Also try to remember...that Edward is actually old enough to be Jacob's great-grandfather. AND you can also look at what he said this way. Since Jacob imprinted upon Renesmee...he currently views her like a sister...so maybe Jacob meant things in a brotherly way...since he viewed Renesmee as his sister...he views the Cullen's as relatives of a type. Maybe that's why he said what he did to Edward. But honestly... What bothered me the most was Jacob...supposed Enemy No. 1 when it came to vampires....sitting around a campfire and making small-talk with them. Jacob would have NEVER done this.