User blog comment:FLittleBastard/Should Renesmee be with Jacob or Nahuel?/@comment-1648141-20111222170256

I think if Stephenie Meyer did do another book revolving around this, Renesmee would choose Jacob and I want her to. Jacob's been through enough heart-break as it is. Plus, Stephenie Meyer made Bella choose Edward (another species) over Jacob, whose closer to her species than Edward, at least he's alive. This way, and because Bella loved Edward first, I think there's a resemblance. Renesmee and Nahuel are closer species (basically because they're the same) but Renesmee loved Jacob first. Since Stephenie Meyer made Bella choose Edward over Jacob I think its more probable that Renesmee would choose Jacob over Nahuel. Then, if she's still in her state of mind, Nahuel will fall in love with Renesmee and Jacob's child, etc...