Talk:Jacob Black and Renesmee Cullen/@comment-24927180-20140601212909/@comment-24927180-20140602042037

See in the book I didn't like their realtionship, but I could live with it, like when Edward said that Jacob never thought about Renesmee being older until Nahuel brought up her aging. So, for me it was still creepy, but it wasn't too bad because he saw her as she was. He didn't think about her growing up.

In the movie it that was just way too much. That one line made me so uncomfortable that I had wanted to leave.

Jacob shouldn't have even said it.

And, that's how I typically see them is that Jacob sees her as a little sister, and she sees Jacob as a big brother, but that one line made it seem like movie Jacob was focused on her future, as did the imprinting really as it focused on adult her as well. They could have showed her at any age, but they focused on her adult age.

The whole movie was focused on what they would be versus the book which had showed what they should be given Renesmee's age.

Making a joke about being someones son-in-law while your soulmate is still in the body of a child....not cute.

I feel like the movie did that in hopes there would be enough of a fan out cry to make a movie about Jacob and Renesmee without there being a book to go of.