Talk:Edward Cullen/@comment-66.87.108.98-20140703171501/@comment-24927180-20140706082346

I don't think so.

Just because Bella thought Edward as comparable to Rosalie's doesn't mean he actually was. Bella is attracted to Edward, so he's always been more beautiful to her. It's a very one-sided view as we don't see what other vampires think of Edward, and if he is actually comparable to Rosalie.

It would be like asking Edward who he thought was more beautiful between Bella and Rosalie. He's attracted to Bella, so he's going to say that she's more beautiful even though it's a fact that Rosalie is more beautiful.