Talk:Jacob Black/@comment-25763921-20141224232739

Who do you guys think would win in a fight - Rosalie or Jacob? In Breaking Dawn, Jacob is extremely arrogant about his ability to fight vampires. When he believes Bella to be dead, he goes to kill the newborn Renesmee, who is being nurtured in Rosalie's arms. He thinks he will be able to phase, snatch the baby out of Rosalie's arms, kill it, and then kill Rosalie before the others get to him. But that just seemed highly doubtful to me.. I'm pretty sure if Jacob succeeded in killing the baby, Rosalie would've ended him then and there, but that's just what I think.