Talk:Volturi confrontation/@comment-7600752-20140208080129

When I read the book, I thought the Cullens would totally cream the Volturi, especially since Bella's power grew so strong and she was able to control and manipulate it so well. However, I've read here on the Wiki that the Cullen side would have lost if going by the movie. Bella never learned to use her power in the movie as well as she did in the book. Carlisle was killed...then Jasper. People have watched the movie in slow motion and insist that they saw Tanya and Kate dead. Another claimed that Rosalie also was killed. At the very end of the battle scene, right after Edward and Bella kill Aro, you can clearly see the Volturi guard overtake both of them. So they'd be killed. The only actual Cullen survivors would have been Alice, Esme, and Emmett. I don't see either Alice or Esme wanting to survive without their mates. Without Rosalie...I see Emmett descending into a barbaric and ruthless vampire and loosing all of the joking and mirthful personality he once had.