User blog comment:Pennyjo/eclipse reshoot's/@comment-66.25.242.111-20100416024335

ok well remeber you ask for input. in my opinion all the movies suck. i love the books very much. i have read them about 4 or more times depends on which one. but just watching the previews make me mad. so i wouldn't really be surprised at what they cut or add. like esme and carlisle's story in the 1st one. i was so ready to start crying at esmes telling of how she tried to commit suicide after her child's death but it never came. and just all of it.like i love the meadow scene in the book but not the movie they just rushed through it all.