User blog comment:EdwardLovesBella/Best Twilight Saga Book?/@comment-3984470-20110930223313

Eclipse, hands-down. Though New Moon is a very, very close second place. Eclipse is my favorite because there are funny moments, romance (that can be a little cringe-worthy, but whatever), and action. Twilight was a frilly, lame story that took forever to get good; New Moon had pathetic Bella at an all-time low; and Breaking Dawn was a laughingstock, to be plain and simple. But I like Eclipse. Plus, Rosalie and Jasper have great background stories.