Talk:Charlie Swan/@comment-213.107.28.228-20100820011202/@comment-58.164.3.197-20100823034800

I hate that you 'talk lyk dis'. He was meant to hate Edward for causing Bella'd depression since he loves her. He's just a protective Dad, nothing wrong with that. I don't think he literally 'hates' Edward, I think he just dislikes him strongly, but it's not like he tries to keep Bella from him or anything, he tries his hardest to accept that she loves him because he loves his daughter.