Talk:Alice Cullen/@comment-25779140-20141129025551/@comment-65.70.243.200-20141221033738

^ Not only that, but how did she see the vision of the Cullen/Volturi battle, when she can't see wolves. Since the wolves were there - Alice should have only been picking up a blank. Some say that Alice imagined the battle and the entire thing was a hoax to fool Aro. But that still wouldn't explain the ending when Alice has the vision of Jacob and Renesmee. So, a possibility is that while Alice was away, she was honing her power... getting better control of it. Kinda like Bella did with her power... or like Kate and her power. So, possibly Alice gained the ability to see hybrids and shapeshifters with her power. Of course NONE of this happened in the book... and what Alice says in the book totally contradicts all this. So, I would say that a screenwriter came up with this idea... to surprise and thrill the audience. And since Meyer is constantly changing her Twilight rules... she went right along with it... although it contradicts everything she's written as well as the other movies. NOTICE that Meyer has never addresses this loophole. It's because she, herself can't explain it.