Talk:Renesmee Cullen/@comment-24.138.166.178-20140623174138/@comment-24927180-20140725043030

While it is true that the whole story is unrealistic there is such thing as taking it too far, and Renesmee takes it too far.

You would think since Meyer knew about Renesmee's  extience for all the years she was writing the Twilight, Saga, she would have taken the time to make the charactrer feel more possbile.

Instead it's kinda just like here's this perfect, amazing, super smart, super already adult, baby, who will grow up in seven years (which makes no sense), and then cease to age at seventeen years old (which again makes no sense).

Then Meyer got annoyed with us because nobody liked Renesmee, but you can't really blame people when you promise through three of four books that babies can't happen just to try and plot twist it on everyone.

I think Meyer could have done a better job at making Renesmee fit better instead she's just kinda of there, and we are just told she's so beatuiful, she's so perfect, wow so amazing, never does anything bad, she's the best thing since sliced bread.

I would love to see Meyer explain how the vampires evolved from/with humans. I feel like I already know that it wouldn't make any sense with what's already been established, and it would be about as much reasoning behing it as there is to how Edward magically knew the shifters were not werewolves during the fight the Volturi.