User blog comment:Haleybug31312/Arguments Bella could play to be turned/@comment-23862393-20131207235516

your right but in the second movie new moon when Bella was talking to Carlisle cause he was stiching heer arm he told her that edward was danmed becaus ehe lives forever and his soul is now satin's so therefore he thinks he and everone else thats a vampire has no soul and they cursed ro live like they are now and they feel like that turning there true love into the same creature they are will make think they cursed that person so thats wh he kept rufusing Bella to change her he only thought to change her if she was dying her self thats why when Renesme was born she was dying so therefore thats when he changed her cause she was dying.