Talk:Bella Swan and Edward Cullen/@comment-109.239.82.36-20150311122753/@comment-68.188.223.225-20180717223437

When does he ever humiliate her? I have been the books and seen all movies and all I saw was that he would tease her a little. And I don't recall him EVER manipulating her - like.. at ALL. And, Edward has shown that he does care about her. He does try to protect her. Why do you think he left her in NM? To make sure she wouldn't get hurt like that again. Of course Bella reacted badly to a very unhealthy degree (Myer what the hell?) But that isn't his fault (Myers for her writing). And honestly, I don't see how he degrades her when tbh she didn't seem to have that much of an issue with it. If ur meaning that he "calls her weak and naive", well...it wouldn't be any different from Alice from saying it. He's a vampire who's lived to centuries, so it'd make sense he'd know what'd be wrong or not. Bella and Edward's relationship has many, many writing issues and unhealthy faults (like stalking like u said), but ur arguments are weak.