User blog comment:Fusedtwilight/Bella vs Victoria/@comment-4054533-20120202000604

Well considering the fact that even though Bella has a lot more control than normal newborns but she has zero fighting ability, Victoria would win. Unless we're going full out Breaking Dawn and Bella learned how to fight from Emmett, Rosalie, Tanya, Eleazar, etc. - in which case, Bella might have a shot.