Talk:Charles/@comment-3217161-20111121051843

A wikiapedia Contributor 1: thats mean he left the cullens when they really needed him and his mate.

Wikiapedia Contributor 2: Yeah well they were with the Volturi because of Renata and they knew the Volturi were lying and didnt want to play their games

Cullen's are HOT!!!:(MINE) The real answer: (Charles and Makenna left becuz they thought they were either going to fight the Cullen's which they knew they were innocent or they will fight againest the Volturi and get themselves killed in the process. I don't blame them leaving. So they haven't done nothing. They are innocent. )