Talk:Alice Cullen/@comment-3984470-20121118221133/@comment-5205908-20121122145026

Clever idea, but here's a thing, Aro can't be deceived by just a THOUGHT, because his touch allows him to see all thoughts that person has ever had.? So if the battle was a thought instead of a vision, Aro would know.? Unless the vision of his demise was so disturbing that he ignored the little details.? But since no one can control the flow of thoughts from them to Aro, it shouldn't be possible for Alice to show Aro just that one vision.? Breaking Dawn Part 2 created some inconsistencies regarding Alice's visions.? Near the end, she saw Edward, Bella, Renesme and Jacob's happy future.? And as pointed out above, Alice shouldn't be able to see hybrids and the shape-shifters, so the movie is kind of messed up