Talk:Renée Dwyer and Phil Dwyer/@comment-99.242.200.205-20140805183004/@comment-7600752-20140901043330

^ I get where you're coming from. But Phil had injured himself and Renee was afraid to leave him. Also consider the fact that Bella wasn't one for attention. She loathed going to graduation... she mostly did if for Charlie. Besides, Bella did NOT want Phil or Renee near Forks since she knew that there was an immanent battle or danger ahead. In fact, Forks was in desperate danger with the Newborn members heading that way. But, you do have a point about a parent missing out on their kid's graduation.