User blog comment:Kirby Phelps (PK)/Alternate Ending: If Bella and Jacob kissed in New Moon/@comment-108.250.12.156-20170423130032

Well it doesn't make sense that Bella is turned into a vampire to be with Jacob forever. Because vampires are like poison to werewolves (well, they are actually shape shifters, but whatever).

You can't tell me that during sex Bella wouldn't accidentally bite Jacob a little too hard and inadvertantly infect him w/ vampire venom, which is poisonous to him. So, yeah, that makes absolutely NO sense.

It was a good story. I just don't see it really making sense in the Twilight universe. Honestly I don't get all the Team Jacob people anyways. Bella never would have chosen Jacob. Ever. Even when Edward was gone in "New moon", she didn't have anything more than friendship feelings for him. She cared for him, yes, but I never got the impression she was really in love w/ Jacob. It always felt more like friendship to me.

Bella wasn't complete w/o Edward. Before she reunited with Edward, and she was thinking about how she might try to explain her feelings to Jacob, she thinks something about how even though part of her was missing, and would always be missing, she did genuinely love Jacob, and he was her best friend, and she wanted to make him happy. But it was like offering him the broken pieces of her heart, because w/o Edward, her heart was irrevocably broken. No amount of love from Jacob could have healed Bella's heart. Jacob would always have been second best...

but second best just isn't good enough.