Talk:Charlie Swan/@comment-92.39.193.89-20110909175708

Okay I am officially confused Bella hasn't done a damn thing to charlie other than protect him if you read the books perticularly the first she even makes edward turn around to protect him. She hated telling him the same thing her mother told him when she left but she HAD to! he is just as stuborn as she is! they have a lovely calming relationship. the only time she ever did anything too bad was running off to save Edward which again she HAD to do! So can someone please tell me other than the actress playing her what's so bad about Bella?!