Talk:Kate/@comment-67.80.166.35-20130321033318/@comment-7600752-20140127071743

I rewatched that scene several times, however I never did see this. Although the scene does show Alec sitting on a body...I could make out was just a bit a shirt and overcoat. The figure did look female...but several of the actresses wore very similar shirts & overcoats so I couldn't tell who it actually was Alec was sitting on. Anyway, the start of the war was very out of character for Carlisle. The book version would never had reacted like that. But, I have to admit, by killing Carlisle, it would have really pist off the other Cullens!