Talk:Reasons why Edward is stupid/@comment-216.137.235.252-20100623131035

I actually agree that Edward is stupid, but some of these reasons are ridiculous..

2] He was born over a hundred years ago. O_o; 4] He has plenty personality.. maybe not the kind you like, but he's got it. 5] How is he judgemental? 6] Yes, he's over protective, but how is he abusive? 8] And that's his fault, how, exactly? 10] You wouldn't? Before he could hear the girl's thoughts, it was just a monster that was killing Bella. Once he heard it, he found out that she loved them both, and he recognized her as his daughter. Like your perspective on someone has never changed?

Like I said, I agree that Edward is stupid, I really don't like him much at all... but from what I see here, you're worse.