Talk:Shape-shifter/@comment-7600752-20140128040526/@comment-7600752-20140215031939

That's true. Most of what you said made kinda sense. Maybe Carlisle had read some books when he was with the Volturi about shapeshifters. Carlisle could have also possibly found out when he met the first pack about a century or so before. Or, as you say, perhaps it was Aro who actually knew the truth about the shapeshifters. HOWEVER, I truly feel that Meyer just pulled that one out of a hat...no explanation for it or anything. THAT"S what I really think happened.