Talk:Life and Death: Twilight Reimagined/@comment-2020973-20151010005043/@comment-7600752-20151012052939

I agree with the fantasy part. It IS fantasy. We ARE glimpsing Twilight through a male perspective...but for me...it's just the WRONG perspective. It's Edward's perspective that I'm interested in. In Midnight Sun, we gain knowledge of Edward's darker self and perspective. Edward is a supernatural creature - and his perspective would have been much more interesting. Not only would readers have a male perspective - but a supernatural perspective as well. Beau?? He's just kinda blah... much like the story.

But, I'm glad you liked the story. Me? Personally I think the entire thing is corny...if not out-right a joke. You (FusedTwilight) could probably write a better Twilight novel than this. I liked ALL the other Twilight novels. This includes Bree Tanner and Midnight Sun (what there was of it.) Practically ANYONE could have done what Meyer did...and I'm not going to praise her for it.

If Rowling decided she was doing the same thing - and gender swapping Harry Potter (Harriet Potter?) - I wouldn't say Hogwarts - but hog-wash! But Rowling wouldn't have the audacity to do something this...silly.