User blog comment:Morningleaf/Why?/@comment-93.172.164.3-20090914170846

half the time jacob is just mean to bella. he cares about her but he thinks hes in love with her. when you love someone you dont hurt them like that. edward is overprotectiv because bella needs him to be- if vampires arnt after her shell get hert all on her own- but when she asks him for space hell give it to her. the only things he cares about are her happiness and well beeing while jacob looks at her more like a prize. besides- bella makes the choice 4 times in a ow! she never had that for jacob- even when she loved him it was as a friend. half the conversations end up with her wanting to kill him and half an hour later remembering that he was there for her. edward loves her and she loves him- besides jacob isnt exactly alone- he has renesmee! the second shes there his pull for bella is gone as anymore then a best friend so honestly in the end- thers not even a question!