Talk:Gianna/@comment-10946245-20130830194954/@comment-7600752-20140502011432

I've wondered the EXACT thing SpiritMonk. How does a human come to be working for the Volturi. Gianna and the other secretaries HAD to have noticed ALL the humans coming in...yet none of them ever left (alive anyway). I respect how you view Gianna. But it was clear that Edward did not like her in the least. Alice basically ignored her. I think ALL the secretaries for the Volturi were pretty dim-witted and doltish. They had to have known that they'd eventually be on the menu.

The reason why the Volturi didn't keep Gianna, Bianca, or Valentina around was because the Volturi couldn't detect that any of them would have a gift or power. If any of these secretaries gave the slightest idea that they might have been gifted...the Volturi would have changed them. Anyway, Bianca and Valentina were made up for the movie. Meyer doesn't have much to say about them...but she did say that Gianna was killed some time after NEW MOON.