User blog comment:TeamEdwardFan/Stephenie's ideas for casting/@comment-189.200.57.202-20101229024351/@comment-2069500-20101229163312

Ah, I always considered Rob's portrayl too wooden. Like he's got the angsty 100+ year old man, but left out the awkward, in-love teenager. See, I'd have liked Edward a lot more if he was portrayed as less wannabe-perfect. Okay, we get it, 100+ years can take the life out of you, yeah, but look at Emmett! And Carlisle! Alice! They're all perfectly fun and peppy. To put in simply, his angst is pointless and throughs everything off. Rob's acting is wooden and his facial expressions look carved.