Talk:Alistair/@comment-99.149.227.125-20130823065251/@comment-24207476-20160205221255

Seriously? Poor guy had his family slaughtered and then lost the only thing he actually cared about (his falcons). Then Carlisle forces him into the situation, risking his life without his consent. Bella was planning on his and the other vampires' deaths buying Jacob enough time to get Reneesme to safety. So, actually, it'd be Bella who was the bad guy.