Talk:Eclipse - book to movie differences/@comment-3412402-20111111032151

Though I'm "Team Edward" (actually, I'm team Jasper or Carlisle :-) ), the Edward of the books is a lot more controlling and generally creepier in the book. There were TOO many details left out of this movie.  It is the least like the book of all of the movies, I think.  The Claire imprinting thing definitely should have been left in.  Her relationship with Charlie is not as developed, nor is her relationship with Jake.  Sigh.  Oh well.  I think they will do a better job with BD.