Talk:Olympic coven/@comment-203.87.199.218-20121229122138/@comment-65.24.114.97-20140425035412

Carlisle did not die. In the movie adaptation of Breaking Dawn, Alice sees a vision of a certain amount of people, including Carlisle, die on the side fighting for Renesmee and other hybrid's sake. But in the book, Alice does not get this vision and therefore it is unknown if Carlisle actually would have died in the book or not.