Talk:Emily Young/@comment-3518524-20140908021529/@comment-16811522-20140914220542

Yeah, you're right. It was August 2003 when the Cullens came back, and a few months after that would be early 2004. Well, that clears up the timeline contradictories, doesn't it?

Hmm, Emily was engaged by March 2006, and if she was in a relationship with Sam since early 2004 to the end of 2006 (which is the end of Breaking Dawn), then that'd be 2 years together. Bella and Edward knew each other from January 2005 and were together from March 2005 to September 2005, and March 2006 until their wedding in August 2006; they were only engaged for two months (June 13 to August 13)! Sam and Emily still had more than enough time before their engagement, being 2 years, so...