User blog comment:SianD/Big Flaw With The Twilight Saga...?/@comment-2034704-20100430010039

Thank you TeamEdward4eve, I do understand that maybe warewolves do have a lesser sense of smell than vampires, but in Eclipse, when Edward breathes on Bella, Jacob smells it the second he hugs her? So really shouldn't he have noticed the smell in Twilight and New Moon?

Anonymous, I understand what you mean, but the boys in the legend were also shape shifters... Yet they reacted to the smell...?