User blog comment:Kirby Phelps (PK)/Breaking Dawn thoughts.../@comment-3412402-20110502220018

The first time I read BD, I almost threw it across the room. It all went downhill for me when Bella got knocked up. I can't stand Renesmee. Edward had even less personality in this book. Jacob got screwed over. I hate how SM felt she had to give everyone a perfect happy ending. WTF was up with telling Charlie? The Charlie from the previous books would have demanded to know what happened to Bella, not all this "need to know" nonsense!! I mean, he's a cop, for crying out loud. I wanted to find just one person who couldn't stand Nessie. Of course, there's Irina. She was killed for her crime of disliking Renesmee. I didn't think there could be a more flat character in the series than Bella, and then Nessie comes along and proves me wrong.