User blog comment:VampiresAndWerewolfsareAwesomeAsHell23/Seth Clearwater's Death/@comment-7600752-20140308015855

I think the biggest shocker of BD was when Carlisle was beheaded by Aro. I knew that wasn't the way the book went...so I thought maybe the Cullens could reattach Carlisle's head to his body later...then the Volturi set Carlisle's body on fire. So basically so many things happened during the movie that I was just stunned. I was surprised when Seth died...and later when Leah died. But I think the biggest shockers was when Carlisle was killed...and then when Jasper was killed. You don't mess with Jasper...cause Alice will chew you up! Anyway, Breaking Dawn was my least favorite novel of the series. Everything just ended way too perfectly (except Irina).