Talk:Volturi confrontation/@comment-97.125.176.237-20130130021005/@comment-72.130.23.73-20130130025740

Well if Carlisle was dead, then there would be no reason to keep the rest of the Cullen's alive....it would give him a reason to take Alice, Edward, and Bella and kill the rest. Aro ripped off Carlisle's head because Carlisle was trying to take back Alice and Aro really wants Alice for her power/gift.