Talk:Breaking Dawn - Part 1 movie reviews/@comment-72.137.4.30-20111204210837

I thought it was pretty good. I found the acting better, the story line seemed to flow like the book which made me happy. I have to admit, though he wasn't in it very much...Charlie was honestly my fav character! The scene when he was saying bye to Bella almost made me cry, and his speech was awesome at the wedding! The wedding seemed very natural, and I thought that scene was well done. Another scene I really liked*spoiler alert* was when the wolves were determining whether to kill the baby. I found that scene very cool, I loved the way the director made the wolves act to their true nature...like Jacob bowing reluctantly to Sam! I thought that was awesome! But when Jacob starting yelling...it kinda ruined the scene for me! If the yelling wasn't there (I know it should be, but I'd rather it not be there) it would of made the scene just slightly less cheesy. Yeah, but I'd give it a 8/10 for the saga. I think Eclipse is better in my opinion, but overall, pretty good.