User blog comment:Kirby Phelps (PK)/Could Breaking Dawn Ruin Jacob's Image?/@comment-82.236.94.196-20110430214457

I get your point. But I disagree when you say that Jacob post-imprinting is not the same. Jacob was jovial and cheerful before wolf transformation and he gets back to that after the imprinting. So the real jacob is what we get at the end. In New Moon and Eclipse he was on edge and struggling I think but in Twilight and Breaking dawn part 2 He is what he is supposed to be as intended by Meyer i think. I get that the imprinting on a baby + the fact that the baby is Bella's is very disturbing but seriously, even if it's fiction, i like the idea of imprinting, I find it beautiful but I know that in real life it could never be like that so i don't try to reason or think in real life-terms when it comes to the twilight saga : after all it's called the forbidden love saga right ? The two loves in this saga, both Edward-Bella and Jacob-Renesmée are so weiiird that at some point you have to stop reasonning to enjoy the story.

Me I still like Jacob, even if I find him annoying with the imprinting thing He becomes less sex-appelling and goes gaga for a baby he hated...so weird. Man, the twilight saga is so weird and disturbing