User blog comment:DenaliLover/I'm sorry, but I just... I just HAVE to point this out/@comment-69.176.180.62-20120213002009

The whole series is full of creepy sub-text, and while nobody can say that Edward and Bella have a healthy or admirable relationship, to me Jacob and Renesmee is much creepier. On top of that, to hand-wave all of Jacob's feelings for Bella as symptomatic of his true love for Renesmee suggests that he has no free will, and is insulting to readers who were taking his emotional struggles seriously. Which is insulting. And then you think about Renesmee, who lives her whole life destined to experience only one romantic relationship - like the betrothed princess in fairy tales, who always runs away from the gilded cage of her life. Which is why I like Alice and Jasper the best. ^_^