Talk:Life and Death: Twilight Reimagined/@comment-27059129-20151009174913/@comment-7600752-20151011233457

Well... I was at the store and saw the book. I thought.. What the he!! - so I bought it. Talk about lame - I've read fan-fiction that was more creative and interesting than this. To me, they guys don't seem SO much like guys. I think they're female alter-egos are overshadowing them.

What's bothering me as well, is Meyer's forewords at the beginning of the book. She wanted to do something special for the 10th year anniversary. She said that she wanted to do another Twilight book for the anniversary, but she didn't have time. She thought about publishing Midnight Sun, but claimed it would have taken too long. BUT, she already HAS part of Midnight Sun already finished - all she had to do was convert the story into Edward's perspective.

I'm still reading - but so far I would give the story a D or C- at the most.