Talk:Battle of the newborn army/@comment-112.205.188.207-20130318015128/@comment-66.138.59.115-20130415031856

The film makers had nothng to do with the "call" about the death of Bree Tanner. Myer, the author of the Twilight Saga, wrote that she died in Eclipse. She also backed this up in "The Short Second Life of Bree Tanner". The filmakers were just going by the books. In Eclipse she's last seen standing in the back behind the Cullen Coven while the Volturi approach. In the book, Jasper forces her to sit on the ground and stay put. Bree is desperately wanting Bella. Bree, a newborn has absolutlely no self control. A lot of readers view Bree as a "good-guy." I disagree since she's murdered hundreds of people to quench her never-ending thirst for blood. Can we pity her since she was forced into the situation that she was put in? Sure, but I bet her victims would be more reluctant to do so. Myer, however, develooped an affection for Bree, and regretted killing her off in Eclipse.