User blog comment:FLittleBastard/Should Renesmee be with Jacob or Nahuel?/@comment-25176701-20151024020153

In a way, it's good she ended up with Jacob. That way, he can still be with his first (and former) love, Bella, but he doesn't have to feel hurt for the rest of her life. The thing I don't like is that (in the future) if Renesmee does start feeling romantically for Jacob (which she most likely will, as SM intended it to be that way), then it wouldn't really be her choice. It would only be because of the whole imprinting thing. Yes, she could technically choose whoever she wants, but the imprinting "persuades" her into choosing Jacob. Had it not been for the imprinting, I don't know who she would choose. She may have not even chosen either of them.

I have always hated the thought of Bella ever ending up with Jacob (for various reasons that I won't get into on here), but at least that was real love. He truly felt that way towards her. It wasn't fake or something that was forced, as imprinting is. Jacob was going to kill Renesmee, so he definitely didn't care for her before. Imprinting on her is the only thing that stopped him from doing that. Not the fact that he was about to kill an innocent child. It had nothing to do with his morals, and him deciding not to kill a baby. He didn't really give a damn about her until imprinting on her. When he grows up, he will only love her for that reasons, and what kind of love is that?

To be clear, I know she won't end up with Nahuel or anyone else, but I still think she deserved to have a choice. She should have been able to choose who she loves. She will never experience real love. She will only experience the "love" she was "forced" into.