User blog comment:Simran bajaj/will edward and bella die in breaking dawn part-2/@comment-83.134.96.110-20121118172107

Alright, I've seen the film and this is what happens.

Aro is still trying to make up arguments - saying that he's not sure she'll not be a threat as she grows older - when Alice appears. She says she'd like to show him proof of Nessie not being a threat to them and he accepts her hand.

Then the vision comes into play, which means that all you'll see after that - Aro taking the hand of Alice - is not real! In the vision the following things happen:

Alice turns around after Aro has seen her thoughts and tell the rest he will attack regardless of the evidence. Bella then asks Jacob to run away with Nessie, which he does and Alice kicks Aro in the air. Aro's men intercept her and try to drag her away, when Carlisle runs towards them to help her. Aro then intercepts Carlisle mid jump and kills him by ripping his head off. Holding Carlisle's head he smiles towards the others. Esme screams and then the fight actually begins.

At first Sam holds the rest of the wolves back, but they'll join in a few moments. Quite a few Volturi vampires are intercepted by the wolves and the Cullens and their teammates. Jasper is seen to easily finish off some of them. But then Jane starts to use her ability on Jasper - at first it doesn't work because Bella protects him, but Alec attacks her which causes her concetration to slip - which allows another vampire to behead him. Alice is devastated (but still can't get loose).

Then Emmet sees Bella being attacked and manages to kill Alec for her. Jane is furious about her brother dieing and meanwhile Alice escapes from her captors.

At the same time Jacob is being followed by a Volturi member, though he manages to stay slightly ahead. Edward knows that Demetri is a good tracker and he chooses that guy to kill next, to prevent him from going after Jake and Nessie.

Meanwhile Seth is attacking a vampire but Jane uses her ability on him which opens the opportunity for another Volturi member to kill him. Leah sees his final moments and starts howling, calling out to Jake at the same time. Momentarily distracted by Leah the vampire is close to attack Jake, but he soon kills the vampire mid run and keeps going.

Bella is being cornered by about four vampires. When Benjamin sees he uses his gift to crack the earth. This makes quite a few Volturi vampires to fall into the lava below. But Esmee is also being pulled along by another vampire, until Leah throws herself at the guy - with a few other Volturi members clinging onto her as they tried to hold her down - and drags him along with her into the lave, succesfully sacrificing herself to save Esmee.

Sam somehow knows of Leah's demise and start to get real pissed off. At the same time Edward is pushed into the gap by Demetri, who he was fighting. Managing to cling to the rock some heavy rocks fall onto him. Somehow though he manages to get out and kill Demetri. When Jane sees all the chaos around her she gets scared. Especially when Alice catches sight of her, knowing that her gift is being blocked by Bella she opts to run away but gets caught by Alice who hands her over to Sam. Said wolf is happy to kill of the vampire who cause the death of two of his former pack.

Aro, seeing one of his most trusted and precious followers die is ready to mingle in the battle himself. Meanwhile Caius attacks the sisters of Irina. But the new lover of one of them helps them kill him. The two vampires with a grudge of 1500 years against the Volturi attack Marcus, who seems to accept his death peacefully. Edward and Bella both attack Aro, but Aro throws Bella against Edward. However, by a succesful teamwork they manage to hold Aro off. Then Edward tries to rip Aro's head off, but doesn't succeed as Aro breaks the hold and in turn tries to kill Edward. Bella intervenes though by jumping on Aro and ripping his head off. Then he sees Bella holding a torch towards his face, while in the back quite a few Volturi close in on them.

So at the end of the vision the registered deaths of the characters whose name we know are:

1. Carlisle

2. Jasper

3. Seth

4. Leah

5. Demetri

6. Jane

7. Caius

8. Marcus

9. Aro

Note; Many others are dead as well, and we can assume that most vampires on the Cullens side have died already when Aro is killed. Seeing as how a lot of Volturi gather around Bella and Edward in the end, which means that they can spare that many as there aren't many other vampires left to fight.

And then the vision ends and Alice informs Aro this is what will happen - his death - if he goes along with his original plan. This, along with testimony of Nahuel is enough for Aro to change his mind. Caius tries to use the presence of the shape shifters as an excuse but Aro won't have none of it and they leave. Meaning that only Irina died, just like in the book.

This vision wasn't described in the book, so we're not sure if this is the vision Alice shows Aro in the book or not. The producers just added it in to create at least some level of suspense and climax, seeing as how little to no action happens in the book (off course the book was already a good size, no one knew what would happen so it was suspenseful when the book first came out and it's a bit more difficult to put it on paper than on screen - on the notion that Meyer had this vision in mind, which I don't think she did.)