User blog comment:Alisha Mjg Barresi/Do You Think The Film 'Breaking Dawn' Will Be ANYTHING Like The Book?/@comment-3412402-20110215000803

I actually didn't think Eclipse was much like the book, at all. I mean, I enjoyed it, but it was much different, as it showed the perspective of the Seattle Newborn Army (some of the material from Bree Tanner). So far, the closest to the book has been New Moon, though my favorite film was twilight.