Talk:Twilight/@comment-96.25.85.115-20110428035706/@comment-60.242.219.179-20121009141249

The book has the same problem. All in all, the situation with James just smacks of an attempt to shoehorn an actual plot into the book. Unfortunately, it comes in too little, too late, and Meyer cops out on the final fight between Edward and James in the worst way; Bella passes out and misses the entire thing so Meyer didn't have to write it. At least you actually get to see James vs. Edward in the movie...